How to Choose Travel Insurance That Actually Pays Out
Most people buy travel insurance in about four minutes, at the end of a flight booking, by ticking the cheapest box.

Most people buy travel insurance in about four minutes, at the end of a flight booking, by ticking the cheapest box. Then a broken ankle, a cancelled trip, or a stolen bag shows them what the policy actually covers, and the answer is often "less than you thought". Choosing travel insurance well takes perhaps 20 minutes, and those minutes are where the real value sits.
I write about budget travel, so I am not going to tell you to buy the most expensive policy. I am going to tell you which numbers to check, which exclusions bite most often, and where cheap cover is perfectly fine.
What travel insurance is really for
A policy bundles several kinds of cover, and they are not equally important. In rough order of how much they can save you:
- Emergency medical treatment and repatriation. A few nights in a private hospital abroad, or an air ambulance home, can run into tens of thousands. This is the part you cannot afford to get wrong.
- Cancellation and curtailment. Refunds prepaid costs if you have to cancel or cut the trip short for a covered reason, such as illness or a family emergency.
- Personal liability. Covers you if you injure someone or damage property.
- Baggage and personal belongings. Useful, but usually capped and full of conditions.
- Travel delay. Small fixed payments, often around 20 to 30 per 12 hours of delay in your currency.
When comparing, start at the top of that list. A policy with excellent baggage cover and a weak medical limit is a bad policy.
The numbers to check before you choose travel insurance
Open the policy summary, often called the key facts or insurance product information document, and look for these figures.
| Item | What to look for |
|---|---|
| Medical cover, Europe | At least 2 million |
| Medical cover, worldwide including USA | At least 5 million, ideally 10 million |
| Cancellation | At least the full prepaid cost of your trip |
| Excess per claim | Ideally 100 or less, and check if it applies per person |
| Single item limit | Higher than your most expensive item, such as a phone or camera |
| Personal liability | At least 1 million |
The excess deserves a second look. A cheap policy with a 250 excess per person means a family of four claiming for a cancelled trip may lose 1,000 before the insurer pays anything.
The exclusions that sink most claims
Claims are rarely rejected for exotic reasons. They fail on the same handful of issues again and again.
Pre-existing medical conditions
If you do not declare a condition you have been treated for, the insurer can refuse any related claim, and sometimes void the policy entirely. Declaring a condition usually adds a modest amount to the premium. Not declaring it can cost you everything.
Activities
Standard policies often exclude skiing, scuba diving below a certain depth, and some hiking above a set altitude, sometimes as low as 2,000 or 3,000 metres. If your trip includes anything active, read the activity list. Even something gentle like open water swimming has conditions, which is one reason I wrote about the checks before wild swimming on a trip.
Alcohol and unattended belongings
Many policies will not pay for injuries linked to heavy drinking, or for items left unattended in a public place or a car. A bag on a beach while you swim usually counts as unattended.
Buying too late
Cancellation cover only protects you from the day you buy. If you book a trip in January and buy insurance in May, anything that went wrong in between is not covered.
Why the card in your wallet is probably not enough
A common tip is to skip travel insurance because a premium bank card or bank account already includes it. Sometimes that cover is excellent. More often, in my experience, it is thinner than people assume.
Card and bank account policies frequently have age limits, often 65 or 70, and many only apply if you paid for the trip with that card. Medical cover can be lower than a standalone policy, pre-existing conditions are often excluded unless you register them, and cancellation limits may be well under the cost of a longer trip. Some only cover trips up to 31 days.
So check it rather than trust it. If your card cover passes the table above, cancel nothing and save the money. If it fails on medical cover or cancellation, buy a separate policy.
Single trip or annual multi-trip cover
A single trip policy for a week in Europe might cost 15 to 30 for a healthy adult under 50. An annual multi-trip policy for Europe often costs 40 to 70. The break-even point is usually two or three trips a year, and weekend breaks count.
Before buying annual cover, check the maximum trip length, often 31 days per trip, and whether domestic trips are included. If you are planning a long backpacking trip, you need a dedicated long-stay or backpacker policy instead.
A 20 minute way to choose travel insurance
- Write down where you are going, for how long, the prepaid cost, and any activities.
- Check what your bank card or account already includes.
- Run two comparison searches with honest medical answers.
- Shortlist three policies that meet the numbers in the table.
- Open each policy wording and search for "excess", "pre-existing", and your planned activities.
- Buy the cheapest of the three that passes, on the same day you book the trip.
- Save the policy number and the 24 hour emergency line in your phone and on paper.
Insurance is just one part of preparing well. If you want the rest of the steps in order, my colleague's guide on how to plan a trip without the stress is a good place to start, and travellers going alone should also read solo travel for beginners.
Frequently asked questions
When should I buy travel insurance?
Buy it as soon as you book the trip. Cancellation cover only starts on the purchase date, so waiting leaves a gap where an illness or emergency would not be covered. Medical cover still works if you buy later, but there is no benefit in waiting.
How much medical cover do I need for travel insurance?
A common guide is at least 2 million for Europe and at least 5 million for worldwide trips that include the USA, where hospital costs are highest. Many travellers choose 10 million for the USA. Repatriation should be included in that figure.
Does travel insurance cover cancelled flights?
Often only partly. If the airline cancels, it usually owes you a refund or rebooking, so the insurer may not pay. Travel insurance helps more with knock-on costs such as unused hotel nights, and with cancellations caused by your own illness or a family emergency.
More in Trip Planning
Trip Planning
How to Stretch Annual Leave Across a Year of Trips
Three years ago I spent fourteen of my twenty five leave days on one trip in August. It was a good trip.
Trip Planning
Planning a Trip Around Local Holidays and Closures
I once arrived in Bologna on the evening of 14 August, pleased with a cheap flight and a room near the centre.
Trip Planning
Group Trip With Friends and How to Plan It Without Rows
A group trip with friends starts in a group chat full of excitement and, far too often, ends with two people not speaking...