Cheap Car Hire Abroad and the Extra Fees Worth Refusing
You booked a car in Portugal for €9 a day, then stood at the rental desk while the agent added €180 of insurance, a fuel charge, and a fee for the second driver.

You booked a car in Portugal for €9 a day, then stood at the rental desk while the agent added €180 of insurance, a fuel charge, and a fee for the second driver. That gap between the online price and the price at the counter is the whole problem with cheap car hire abroad. The headline rate is real, but it only stays cheap if you know which extras to refuse and which ones you actually need.
I have hired cars in about 20 countries on a tight budget, and I have paid for most of the mistakes below at least once. Here is how to keep a cheap rental cheap.
Why cheap car hire abroad gets expensive at the desk
Low base rates are often loss leaders. The rental company makes its money on add ons sold at the counter, where you are tired, the queue behind you is long, and the agent knows you need the car. Typical upsells and what they usually cost per day in southern Europe:
| Extra | Typical desk price | Do you need it? |
|---|---|---|
| Excess waiver or "super cover" | €15 to €35 a day | Usually cheaper bought separately |
| Additional driver | €5 to €12 a day | Only if you will share driving |
| GPS unit | €8 to €15 a day | No, use your phone with offline maps |
| Child seat | €6 to €12 a day, often capped | Legally yes; bringing your own can be cheaper |
| Full to empty fuel | Full tank plus a service fee of €20 to €35 | Almost never |
| Toll transponder | €1.50 to €3 a day plus tolls | Yes in Portugal, optional elsewhere |
Young drivers get hit hardest. Under 25s often pay a surcharge of €10 to €25 a day, and some firms cap it per rental while others do not, so compare the total rather than the day rate.
On a seven day rental, saying yes to everything can turn a €63 booking into well over €350.
The excess and how to cover it for less
Almost every rental in Europe includes basic damage cover with a high excess, often €1,000 to €2,500. That is the amount you pay if the car is scratched or damaged. The desk will offer to cut it to zero for €20 or more a day.
The cheaper option is standalone car hire excess insurance, bought before you travel. An annual policy for Europe often costs £40 to £60, about the same as two or three days of the desk product. If something happens, you pay the rental company the excess, then claim it back.
Two catches. First, the rental company will still hold the full excess on your credit card as a deposit, so you need a card with enough limit, and it must be a credit card in the main driver's name. Debit cards are refused at many desks or force you to buy their cover. Second, read what your policy covers: tyres, windscreen and the underside of the car are often excluded from basic cover but included in good standalone policies. Our guide to choosing travel insurance that actually pays out has more on reading the small print.
Booking steps that keep the price down
- Book 4 to 8 weeks out. Rates rise sharply in the last two weeks before summer and school holidays. Book with free cancellation and check again a fortnight before; if the price drops, rebook.
- Compare airport and town pick ups. Airport locations add a premium fee, often €25 to €50 per rental. A town office a short bus ride away can be much cheaper, if its opening hours fit your flight.
- Choose full to full fuel. You collect with a full tank and return it full. Fill up within 10 km of the drop off and keep the receipt.
- Pick the smallest car that fits your bags. Old towns, narrow mountain roads and tight parking all favour a small car, and fuel costs less.
- Pay in the local currency. If the card machine offers to charge you in your home currency, decline. The conversion rate is usually poor, a trap we cover in avoiding foreign transaction fees.
- Travel off peak if you can. A car on Crete in late May or early October can cost half what it does in August, one of the many savings in shoulder season travel.
Why the cheapest company is not always the cheapest rental
The usual advice is to sort by price and take the lowest. I think that is where many people lose money. The very cheapest firms often sit off airport, run a shuttle that comes every 40 minutes, and have the hardest sell at the desk. Some are strict on tiny scratches at return and charge an admin fee of €40 to €60 on top of any damage.
A rental at €14 a day from a company with clear fuel rules, a desk in the terminal and fair reviews about damage claims often ends up cheaper than a €7 a day deal that costs an hour of your holiday and an argument at drop off. Read recent reviews for that exact branch, not the brand as a whole, and look for complaints about deposits and damage charges in particular.
Protecting yourself at pick up and return
Ten minutes at each end prevents most disputes.
- Film a slow walk around the car before you drive off, including wheels, roof, windscreen and the interior. Make sure the video has the date and time.
- Check that every existing mark is noted on the rental form. If the agent says "do not worry about small ones," ask them to write it down anyway.
- Photograph the fuel gauge and mileage at pick up and return.
- Return during opening hours if possible, and get someone to sign the car back in. Dropping keys in a box after hours leaves the inspection to them.
- Watch your card statement for 60 days. Late damage or fuel charges can appear weeks after you get home.
Also check local rules before you go. France expects a reflective vest within reach of the driver and a warning triangle in the car, and some countries need an International Driving Permit for licences from outside the region. The rental car should come equipped, but it is your fine if it is missing.
Frequently asked questions
Should I buy the excess insurance at the rental desk?
Usually not. Standalone excess insurance bought before your trip often costs less for a whole year than the desk charges for a few days. The trade off is that you pay any excess first and claim it back afterwards.
Can I hire a car abroad with a debit card?
Some companies accept debit cards, but many either refuse them or require you to buy their own full insurance. A credit card in the main driver's name with enough limit for the deposit is the safest choice.
Is it cheaper to rent a car at the airport or in town?
Town offices are often cheaper because they skip the airport premium fee. The saving can be €25 to €50 per rental, but check opening hours and the cost of getting there before you book.
More in Budget Travel
Budget Travel
City Tourist Cards and When They Actually Pay Off
I bought a 72 hour city card in Vienna once, on the platform, before I had even decided what I wanted to see.
Budget Travel
House Sitting for Free Accommodation and How It Works
Accommodation is usually the biggest single line in a trip budget, often 40 to 50 percent of the total once flights are paid.
Budget Travel
Free Walking Tours and How Much You Should Really Tip
You sign up for a free walking tour to save money, spend two and a half hours following a guide around the old town, and then...